Why Did They Get Rid of Andrew Garfield as Spiderman?

Why Did They Get Rid of Andrew Garfield as Spiderman?

Spiderman, one of the most beloved superheroes, has seen various actors donning the iconic red and blue suit over the years. From Tobey Maguire to Andrew Garfield and finally Tom Holland, fans have witnessed different interpretations of the web-slinger.

While each actor brought their unique charm to the character, it was a surprise for many when Andrew Garfield’s portrayal came to an end. Let’s delve into why they decided to replace him.

The Amazing Spiderman Series

Andrew Garfield first took on the role of Peter Parker/Spiderman in 2012’s “The Amazing Spiderman.” The movie received mixed reviews from both critics and fans alike.

Although Garfield’s portrayal was well-received, there were some issues with the direction of the franchise. Despite a strong start, “The Amazing Spiderman” series failed to capture the same level of success as its predecessors.

  • Lackluster Box Office Performance: While “The Amazing Spiderman” had a solid opening weekend at the box office, its overall performance fell short compared to Sam Raimi’s original trilogy. The sequel, “The Amazing Spiderman 2,” also failed to meet expectations critically and commercially.
  • Creative Differences: Reports suggested that there were creative differences between Sony Pictures (the studio behind “The Amazing Spiderman” series) and Marvel Studios (which had recently started its own Marvel Cinematic Universe). These differences impacted the direction of the character and storyline.

The Sony-Marvel Deal

In 2015, Sony Pictures announced a partnership with Marvel Studios that would allow Spiderman to join the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU). This meant that Andrew Garfield’s version of Spiderman would be replaced by a new actor to fit into the established universe.

Marvel’s Reboot with Tom Holland

Tom Holland was introduced as the new Spiderman in 2016’s “Captain America: Civil War.” His portrayal was met with widespread acclaim, capturing the youthful spirit and humor of Peter Parker. Marvel’s decision to reboot the character and cast a younger actor aligned with their vision of showcasing Spiderman as a high school student within the MCU.

The collaboration between Sony Pictures and Marvel Studios proved successful, as Tom Holland’s Spiderman became an integral part of the MCU. He starred in standalone movies like “Spiderman: Homecoming,” “Spiderman: Far From Home,” and appeared in ensemble films such as “Avengers: Infinity War” and “Avengers: Endgame.”


While Andrew Garfield’s portrayal of Spiderman was appreciated by many fans, the combination of lackluster box office performance, creative differences, and Sony’s partnership with Marvel Studios led to his departure from the role. The decision to replace him with Tom Holland allowed for a fresh start and reinvigorated interest in the character within the highly successful Marvel Cinematic Universe.

As fans eagerly await future Spiderman adventures, it is clear that this iconic superhero will continue to evolve in the hands of talented actors who bring their own unique interpretations to Peter Parker’s alter ego.